Editing Opportunities: Selecting an edit point
There is no real formula for selecting an edit point, but there are editing
conventions: Selecting an edit point depends on pacing, content, editor’s
objective for creating and controlling emotion.
Editing Conventions
Entrance cut: Subject entering the frame
Exit Cut: Subject leaving the frame
Action cut: two views of the same action within a frame cut together
Look Off: Somewhere in the frame there is an off screen reference, motion,
or glance.
Entrance Cuts
The central question: How long do we wait before the subject/car/plane
etc enters the frame?
option #1 |
|
cut to
the subject already in the frame
(cold cut)
|
- creates potential
continuity problems when cutting into a sequence of the same action
- cut
at this point, the shot may be unnecessarily short: the subject might
be moving away from us and becoming less significant.
- cutting when
the subject is already in the frame makes the subject appear as part
of the background; the subject no longer stands out.
|
option #2 |
|
| Cut
to the subject entering the frame |
- Using
this option creates a conflict in the viewers mind: when the edit occurs,
the viewers
are looking at the frame, trying to orient themselves to see what
it is they are looking at .... at the same time, the movement of the
subject
entering the frame draws the viewer’s eye to see what it is
that is moving.
- Whenever we set up a conflict
in the mind of the viewer, the edit is not as smooth
as it should be - the edit draws attention to itself.
|
option #3 |
|
| Cut
to the frame empty before the subject appears |
- Allows the audience
to look at a new frame and orient themselves without being distracted.
- When the subject does enter
the frame, the audience looks at the subject at the same time; the
subject now becomes the dominate subject in the
frame rather than
part of the landscape.
|
By properly
selecting the edit point, the editor manipulates the audience by
making them look at and pay attention to what we think is important.
Don’t
over do it. Holding too long on an empty frame creates restlessness
on the part of the audience. They become bored and their eyes begin to
wander trying to discover what they are supposed to be looking at.
How long is too
long? ... depends on how visually stimulating the shot is.
When to use an
entrance cut:
|
Back
to top
Exit Cuts
The main question here is: When do we make our exit cut???
Option
#1 |
|
Before the
subject leaves the frame?
|
too abrupt - similar
abruptness occurs when cutting on a zoom |
Option
#2 |
|
After the subject
has left the frame, when the frame is empty?
|
A mistake: this keeps
the audience guessing because the audience does not interpret an empty
frame as empty, but rather thinks that the editor has left it empty for
a reason; once the subject has left the frame it begins to scan all over
the frame to discover what it is you want them to see and how it relates
to the rest of the story or program; meanwhile, they are not paying attention
to your message.
|
Option #3 |
|
| As the
subject is leaving the frame?? |
- The best
option: this is smoothest option.
- Think about
what happens with the viewers eyes:
- as the viewer
is concentrating on an object that is moving to the edge of the frame,
there is a point
where the viewer can no longer
watch
the object. At that
instant, the viewer’s eyes scan back across the frame to look for
something else to concentrate on. It’s while the eyes are in motion
that we make our edit: because while our eyes are in motion we are blind;
the way
we see is that our eyes work by
giving us a succession of cuts.
|
The
process of executing an effective exit cut:
- editor must be
looking at what the audience is looking at. (there is no sense in
making an
exit cut if no one is watching the object
leave the frame)
- Identify the
centre of interest
- wait for the
subject to approach the edge of the frame
- cut during
the audience’s
eye movement as they’re looking for the
next thing to concentrate on
- Guidelines for
identifying the centre of interest in a shot:
- the eye is
drawn to bright colors vs dark colors
- the eye is
drawn to animate rather than inanimate objects
- we are drawn
to look at people and the places where people are
- our eyes
are drawn to moving objects rather than static ones.
|
Back to Top
The
Action cut
Main question? Where do we make the cut??? Before during or after the action????
Option #1 |
|
Cutting
before the action
|
- static
- unmotivated
- leads
the audience
|
Option #2 |
|
Cutting
after the action:
|
- Static
- Unmotivated
- Edit
appears as an afterthought
|
Option #3 |
|
Cutting
during the action:
|
- Best edit
point is during that action once an action has begun within the frame,
cutting
to a continuation of that action in another frame is interpreted
as a
better view of what is going on.
- A cut performed
on action is the smoothest edit that can be performed
|
| General Guidelines
for cutting on action: (outgoing shoot) |
- Allow for
about a third of the action to occur before the audience will be clearly
looking at it
don’t cut too late into the action
- Cut before
the action is half complete (otherwise the eyes of the viewer will
have
moved on to other things in the
frame.
|
| What about the incoming
shot? |
- The technical match
almost never works
- Why? Because the
audience is not expecting the incoming shot; when it comes they try
to reorient themselves - the
mental blink during the edit causes the viewers
to miss the first few frames of the incoming shot
- The solution: begin
by finding the technical match then back up the edit point for the
incoming
shot; overlap about three frames for a smooth edit.
|
- The
action cut is the most powerful edit tool we can use because it
binds the two actions together as if they were taking place in one
shot;
- Action cuts are
seamless and are not perceived as two different shots
- We should pursue
action cuts whenever possible
- action cuts require
coverage of the action from different angles
- action cuts require
overlap of the action
|
Back to Top
The Look Off
A cut motivated by a head turn, a gesture, an off screen reference or a
verbal reference
Head turn
Key question: When to cut? During or after the head turn? |
- During
head turn interrupts completion of the action
- After the head
turn is complete is the proper edit point
- How soon to
cut after the head turn depends on how urgent the head turn is.
- The
key thing about a look off is learning to recognize the potential
that exists in the field footage; look for gestures, looks
and
off-screen references that
offer editing opportunities.
|
| |
|
Summary
- Editing begins in the
field with producer and sensitivity of the camera person
- Common fault is
to still think of footage as shots: wide shots, medium
shots and close ups
- Quality of field footage
should also be as gaged by the number of editing opportunities in the material:
entrances,
exits; action;
overlap in the
action; action covered
by more than one camera angle; are there off-screen references
and head turns that can be used as editing opportunities?
Back
to TOP
Bonus
Project Evaluation
...
| Length |
/20 |
|
| - 1 mark for every
+ or - 5 frames |
|
|
|
| Camera Work |
|
|
| level shots |
|
|
| head room |
|
|
| nose room |
|
|
|
| Editing |
|
|
| smooth cross
disolves |
 |
|
|